Anguilla may not be the first thing that comes to mind when you think of exotic beach destinations, but for years, this island of corals and limestone has been steadily drawing in well-to-do travelers looking for an alternative to St Barths or other destinations.
Not only do you get a gorgeous landscape, but the county also has the most indulgent resorts in town!
So, if a trip to Anguilla is on your radar, check out this Belmond Cap Juluca vs. Four Seasons Resort Anguilla comparison to find out which one is best for you.
Learn more about our points consulting services!
Quick Glance: Belmond Cap Juluca vs. Four Seasons Anguilla
| Belmond Cap Juluca | Four Seasons Anguilla | |
| Location | Maundays Bay, AI-2640, Anguilla, British West Indies | Barnes Bay, West End 2640, Anguilla |
| Getting There | After arriving in Anguilla, take a cab from the nearest airport, the Clayton J. Lloyd (AXA), or take a 20-minute boat ride from St. Maarten. The resort can arrange your boat transfer whether it’s private, shared, or via public ferry. | Guests fly into the island from St. Maarten or Puerto Rico. The nearest airport is Clayton J. Lloyd (AXA) in Anguilla. Once you reach this airport, it’ll be around 15 to 25 minutes to reach the hotel. |
| Room | 64 rooms and 44 suites | 181 rooms and suites |
| Amenities | Outdoor swimming pool, meeting room, tennis court, spa, gym, business center, beach access | 3 swimming pools, a fitness center, basketball court, tennis court, spa, kid’s club |
| Food and Dining | 4 restaurants and bars | 4 restaurants and a bar |
| Staff and Guest Services | Great. They are attentive with exclusive staff designated in certain areas like the beach. | Amazing service is always expected at any Four Seasons resort. |
| Price | Cash rates begin at $1,279 to $3,069 per night. (Average of $2,100). | For cash booking, they begin at $1,012 per night to $3,245 per night (average $2,350). |
| Points Redemption | No, at the moment, there are no options to redeem points for a free night. | No, not at the moment. |
The Details: Belmond Cap Juluca vs. Four Seasons Anguilla
Belmond Cap Juluca
Belmond Cap Juluca-Spa. Image Credit: Belmond Cap Juluca
This beachfront escape has been entertaining guests since it first opened its doors in 1988. Through the years, it has switched owners and seen few updates to what is now a beloved five-star destination for luxury vacationers everywhere.
Location
Located on Maundays Village Beach, Belmond Cap Juluca was first designed by California architect, Oscar Farmer. The resort villas echo a Greco-Moorish design dotting the crescent shape of the bay. Because of its sheltered location, the resort feels like a private getaway – far from the busy tourist spots.
In 2017, the resort was acquired by the LVMH group – continuing the legacy of Belmond Cap Juluca and elevating the resort further into the height of glamour and classiness.
To reach the property, guests can fly into Anguilla or take a boat from St. Maarten. The nearest airport, Clayton J. Lloyd International Airport (AXA) is only a 10-20 minute car ride away from the resort.
You can also arrange private or shared ferry transfers from St. Maarten. Just contact the resort ahead of time if you need help making these arrangements.
Room
Belmond Cap Juluca – Interior. Image Credit: Belmond Cap Juluca
Belmond Cap Juluca offers 66 guest rooms with 44 suites. Starter villas measure 670 to 750 square feet, complete with romantic four-poster beds in Italian Frette linens, beautiful abaca chairs, and striking armoires.
White walls inject brightness into the space while delicate details on the handmade limestone floor introduce a Moorish flavor to the room.
Each room has a terrace with chairs for lounging. Most villas are only steps away from the beach, especially the starter villas. Modern touches like a 55-inch smart TV, a stocked minibar, and a Bang & Olufsen sound system are also in the room.
The bathroom is equally grand with twin sinks, a deep soaking tub, spacious showers, a toilet, and branded L’Occitane en Provence toiletries.
Opting for higher-end rooms means you get more space with some containing private plunge pools and dedicated living spaces.
Amenities
Offering a range of amenities, the resort provides cruiser-style bicycles to make it easy for you to explore the resort. There are also mini buggies roving around to take you from one area to the next, in case you don’t want to walk.
Guests have beach access and each room is provided with two beach loungers should they want to lounge by the water. Just keep in mind the beaches at Anguilla are public beaches so almost anyone can go there. If you prefer, you can stay at the infinity pool where there’s a pool bar for cocktails and light bites.
Arawak Spa is named after the first inhabitants of the island. The spa offers a host of special treatments offered at three dedicated treatment rooms right by the beach. In addition, there’s a fitness center with modern equipment, several tennis courts, a business center, a meeting room, as well as a kid’s club.
Ready to elevate your travel lifestyle? Make an appointment with a points consultant today and discover a whole new way of luxury travel!
Food and Dining
Belmond Cap Juluca – Beach Dining. Image Credit: Belmond Cap Juluca
Belmond Cap Juluca is not only known for its gorgeous villas, but it also has some of the best dining spots in Anguilla.
The signature restaurant, Pimms, is touted as one of the most romantic restaurants in the country. Savor authentic Anguillan cuisine with Caribbean flavors alongside international classics. With a light and airy ambiance, the restaurant offers multi-course meals made from the freshest local ingredients.
Right next door is Cips, an offshoot of Cipriania’s restaurant. Gorge on Italian comfort food while dining al fresco. Try out their famous carpaccio or go for a daily buffet breakfast here. Meanwhile, à la carte dishes are also available for a fee.
If you prefer dining beachside, then drop by The Cap Shack. Unwind with friends or family while enjoying a beach barbecue feast. There’s reggae music, tapas, as well as rum punches!
For a poolside feast, Uchu serves a choice selection of light bites and refreshing cocktails by day. At night, Uchu provides delightful Peruvian cuisine to tantalize your taste buds.
Earn points faster and smarter just by using your credit card! Sign up for the best travel credit cards available today.
Staff and Guest Services
Service is phenomenal here. A lot of the staff have been with Belmond Cap Juluca for years and the hotel knows how to take care of its employees. After the hotel’s forced closure and renovation due to a hurricane, the majority of the staff were kept employed doing landscape work as well as restoration.
You can tell a lot of the staff care for the guests, remembering their choice of drinks, offering extra service, and ensuring each guest is comfortable throughout their stay.
Price
If you want to book a stay here in cash, standard room rates begin at $1,279 to $3,069 per night. (Average of $2,100).
Points Redemption
As of now, there is no option to book Belmond Cap Juluca using points.
The Points University is the place to be if you want to receive step-by-step instructions on how to use points to book luxury hotels and premium flights.
Who Is It For?
Although it’s popular with honeymooners and couples, Belmond Cap Juluca is a resort made for everyone. It can accommodate families and groups of friends, with plenty of amenities to keep everyone happy and entertained during their stay.
Belmond Cap Juluca Gallery
Belmond Cap Juluca – Beach. Image Credit: Belmond Cap Juluca
Belmond Cap Juluca – Garden. Image Credit: Belmond Cap Juluca
Belmond Cap Juluca – Plunge Pool. Image Credit: Belmond Cap Juluca
Four Seasons Resort & Residences Anguilla
Four Seasons Anguilla – Beach. Image Credit: Four Seasons Anguilla
The Four Seasons is a trusted hotel brand known for delivering class and luxury. And while there’s a bevy of famous Four Seasons Resorts in the world, there are also lesser-known gems in the brand’s rich portfolio – among them Four Seasons Anguilla.
Location
Framed by beautiful white sandy beaches, the Four Seasons Anguilla is a British territory on the Western portion of the island.
To reach the resort, you need to fly from Princess Juliana International Airport (SXM) in St. Maarten and into the Clayton J. Lloyd International Airport (AXA) in Anguilla. Alternatively, you can also take a 25-30 minute ferry ride from St. Maarten.
Once in Anguilla, it will be a 15-25 minute car ride to reach the Four Seasons Resort Anguilla.
Room
Four Seasons Anguilla – Private Plunge Pool. Image Credit: Four Seasons Anguilla
Take your pick from a multitude of lavish abodes during your stay at the Four Seasons Anguilla.
The resort has 181 guest rooms, divided into 70 rooms, 50 suites as well as 24 beachfront villas, 4 townhomes, and 33 residences.
Resort View Rooms serve as the entry-level space at 618 square feet. This includes 123 square feet of balcony or terrace space. Cream-colored and taupe tones create a fresh feeling while the marble floors and driftwood touches echo a fun beach vibe.
Entry-level spaces provide courtyard views but higher-category rooms give guests views of the ocean. Each room has a plush king bed dressed in premium linens and monogrammed pillowcases.
Custom-designed furniture and accessories create a cozy, branded feel while convenient amenities like an espresso machine, flatscreen TV, gaming consoles (upon request), and fully stocked minibar create a welcome touch.
Inside the bathroom are thick terry robes, full-sized bottles of Italian bath products, a spacious shower, a tub, a toilet, and slippers too!
Amenities
To keep yourself entertained, take a dip at any of the 3 swimming pools. The pool area is lined with comfortable chairs and towels and is always manned by helpful staff ready to bring you anything from lunch to a rum punch.
There are two beaches, Meads Bay Beach and Barnes Bay Beach. Loungers are also provided here but during high tide, the number of chairs is lessened to accommodate the rising waters.
For the ultimate indulgence, try out the resort’s luxurious spa. It has two levels and is located near the central pool. The spa has art deco decor with contemporary furnishings along with 13 indoor treatment rooms, including a couple’s room.
You’ll also find a huge fitness center with dedicated spaces for bike spinning and a weight room. Those traveling with kids can join the Kids For All Seasons (KFAS) Program where children can go on a nature walk, make jewelry, or do scavenger hunts.
Those into sports will love the basketball and tennis courts, or the putting green and climbing wall.
Food and Dining
Four Seasons Anguilla – Dining. Image Credit: Four Seasons Anguilla
Feast on a lavish breakfast at SALT, the resort’s signature restaurant. It has a range of delicious dishes including gluten-free and vegan meal options. At night, the restaurant is known for serving amazing Caribbean cuisine, emphasizing seafood.
Need a light lunch by the beach? Head to the Half Shell Beach Bar. You can grab light bites as well as refreshing frozen drinks while here. If you want a private dinner, this is also a great location to book. Another great lunch spot is Bamboo Bar & Grill, which serves lunch meals and beach cocktails.
Finally, if you want to relax, The Sunset Lounge is the perfect place for a delicious negroni, some local music, and a stunning sunset view to cap your day.
Staff and Guest Services
As expected from a top-tier resort, the service is exceptional here. The staff are incredibly hospitable, making you feel like royalty every step of the way.
All the senior managers always find the time to drop by and ask if everything is okay or if you need anything. Plus, the staff seem to know your name and what you need even before you ask. It’s quite a treat!
Price
For cash rates, they start at $1,012 per night to $3,245 per night (average $2,350).
Points Redemption
At the moment, it’s not possible to book the Four Seasons Resort Anguilla using points.
Who Is It For?
This destination property is perfect for solo travelers, honeymooners, and even large families. It has a Western feel as opposed to a Caribbean vibe, so if you’re looking for a more intimate Caribbean-style hotel, this may not be for you.
Four Seasons Anguilla Gallery
Four Seasons Anguilla. Image Credit: Four Seasons Anguilla
Four Seasons Anguilla – Spa. Image Credit: Four Seasons Anguilla
Four Seasons Anguilla – Swing Bed. Image Credit: Four Seasons Anguilla
Best For: Which Resort Should You Go For?
| Winner | What Makes It Great | |
| Best for Food | Belmond Cap Juluca | With Pimms being one of the best restaurants in Anguilla, Belmond Cap Juluca wins this one. |
| Best for Pools | Four Seasons Resort Anguilla | The Four Seasons Resort Anguilla offers 3 swimming pools so you can choose which ones to enjoy. |
| Best for Spa | Four Seasons Resort Anguilla | Equipped with a two-level spa and a host of treatment rooms, you can have a relaxing spa day at the Four Seasons. |
| Best for Beaches | Tie | Both resorts have access to fantastic beaches. |
| Best For Adults | Belmond Cap Juluca | Belmond Cap Juluca offers a slightly more intimate escape perfect for honeymooners and adults. |
| Best for Families | Four Seasons Resort Anguilla | Because of its extensive kid’s club, the Four Seasons Resort Anguilla is the better choice for families, especially with kids around. |
| Best Location | Tie | Both resorts have a great location. |
| Best for a Calm Vacation | Belmond Cap Juluca | The calmer resort of the two is Belmond Cap Juluca. |
| Best for Diving or Snorkeling | Belmond Cap Juluca | Cap Juluca is popular for swimming and snorkeling thanks to its abundant sea life and crystal clear waters. |
| Best for Service | Four Seasons Resort Anguilla | Service at the Four Seasons Resort Anguilla is simply amazing! |
| Most Exclusive | Belmond Cap Juluca | Belmond Cap Juluca is slightly more exclusive than the Four Seasons Resort Anguilla. |
Wrapping Up
Anguilla has a lot to offer if you’re after a relaxing Caribbean vacation. It has fantastic beaches, sumptuous cuisine, and truly warm and welcoming locals.
Both the Belmond Cap Juluca and the Four Seasons Resort Anguilla have the finest amenities and service on the island. The Belmond Cap Juluca has experience and history behind them. Built earlier and offering more exclusivity, honeymooners, and couples will love its romantic Greco-Moorish villas and beachfront location.
On the other hand, the Four Seasons Resort Anguilla promises all the amenities you can dream of in a fantastic vacation. The stunning and indulgent guestrooms assure a restful stay while the food and service will leave you wanting to stay longer.
Whichever resort you opt for, you’re sure to have a grand time.
Safe travels!