St. Barts, St. Barths, or Saint Barthélemy – however, you want to spell it, there’s no doubt St. Barts is one of those destinations listed on every luxury traveler’s bucket list.
From the moment you arrive on the islands, you’ll glimpse crystalline waters, striking yachts, exquisite white sandy beaches, and attractive sunbathers with sun hats and designer beach bags. Fantastic high-end resorts are also hidden away in this gorgeous island paradise.
Two of the most glamorous resorts in St. Barts are Eden Rock and Cheval Blanc. Get to know these two resorts in this Eden Rock St Barths and Cheval Blanc St-Barth comparison.
Learn more about our points consulting services!
Quick Glance: Eden Rock St Barths vs. Cheval Blanc St-Barth
| Eden Rock St Barths | Cheval Blanc St-Barth | |
| Location | Baie de Saint Jean, St. Barthélemy | Baie des Flamands, Saint-Barthélemy |
| Getting There | Reach Eden Rock via an airport shuttle, private car, or taxi. The nearest airport is the St. Barts Airport (SBH). | To reach the resort, you need to take a charter plane to reach St. Barts. Once you reach the island, you can arrange for a private car from the resort or take a taxi. |
| Room | 37 rooms and suites | 61 rooms and suites |
| Amenities | Beach access, gym, small library, spa, fitness center, private pools | Fitness center, Guerlain Spa, private pool, beach access, boutique shops |
| Food and Dining | 3 restaurants and bars | 2 restaurants and 1 bar |
| Staff and Guest Services | Amazing! They are friendly, professional, and attentive. | Fantastic! They go above and beyond to ensure guests are nurtured and will feel special. |
| Price | Cash rates begin at $1,669 to $1,911 per night. (Average of $1,477). | Cash bookings are pricey, starting at $950 per night to $2,657 per night (average $1,450). |
| Points Redemption | No, at the moment, there are no options to redeem points for a free night. | No, not at this time. Cheval Blanc St. Barts has no option to book on points. |
The Details: Eden Rock St Barths vs. Cheval Blanc St-Barth
Eden Rock St Barths
Eden Rock St Barths – Beach. Image Credit: Eden Rock St Barths
There’s a reason why Eden Rock St Barths is a favorite for celebrities since the days of Greta Garbo. It’s because it’s the first luxury hotel ever created on the island when French aviator Remy de Haenen landed here in the 1950s.
By 1995, the Matthews family purchased the property and it is now in part managed by the Oetker Collection.
Location
Located within a few minutes from the airport, reaching the resort is not a problem once you arrive on the island. You can take a private car go for a rental, use a taxi, or hire an airport shuttle.
The resort is on St. Jeans Bay with the main building set right on a rock on the turquoise waters. Nikki Beach and its stunning blonde sand surround the rest of the resort, creating a sense of calm and relaxation.
Room
Eden Rock St Barths – Room View. Image Credit: Eden Rock St Barths
Kept private and small for a reason, there are only 37 rooms on this resort. Each room is prepared to be cozy and unique with an air of refinement hinted in each space.
Starter rooms start at 645 square feet with a built-in terrace facing the water. Each room includes a large king bed with white sheets. These are placed next to tall glass windows leading to the balcony where there’s an incredible view of the Caribbean.
Inside the room are mini-libraries, chic orange leather chairs, a desk with a woven wicker chair, and a mix of original as well as antique fine art all around.
There are personal touches as well as elegant knick-knacks that infuse the room with a posh homey vibe instead of a traditional hotel room feel.
Standard amenities include a minibar, a fridge, and in higher room categories, a private pool. Spacious bathrooms are equally grand with deep soaking tubs, a walk-in shower, fluffy towels, and Ligne St. Barth toiletries.
Amenities
Eden Rock St Barths – Gym. Image Credit: Eden Rock St Barths
Although it’s not a massive resort, there are plenty of things to keep you busy. There’s a small yet brightly-lit gym with modern equipment like a treadmill and weights.
If you come here to relax, the water is only a few meters away. You can bask under the glorious sunshine on the sand or go into the water to kayak, swim, or snorkel. There’s no communal pool but if you book a room with a private plunge pool, these all face the ocean. You can also get massages and other treatments to help you relax your body and mind by booking an appointment at the spa.
Guests can walk around the area to visit various restaurants and shops. The hotel also has a shop where you can get beachwear and essentials. And if you fancy, there’s even a professional recording studio onsite.
Speak to a points consultant if you’re ready to travel a new way! A points consultant can help you navigate the world of points hacking – help you book premium first-class flights and even luxury hotel bookings.
Food and Dining
Eden Rock St Barths – Bar. Image Credit: Eden Rock St Barths
Dining at Edens Rock St. Barts is a treat.
The Sand Bar, headed by Chef Jean-Georges Vongerichten, is Eden Rock’s signature restaurant. It has a laid-back atmosphere by the beach and serves up classics from truffle pizza to a delicious gourmet meal.
The Rémy Bar & Salon is named after the founder and his pioneering spirit. Park yourself here and grab signature cocktails carefully curated by expert mixologists.
Finally, right on St. Jean Beach is the iconic Beach Bar. Try the Frozés (frozen rosé) or maybe the ginger margaritas. A lavish daily breakfast buffet is available with the room rate.
The best travel credit cards offer excellent value when it comes to earning points for every swipe.
Staff and Guest Services
One thing guests rave about is how the staff and managers care for every guest. The manager knows every guest by name while every staff and barmen are equally accommodating. They do everything with a smile and without any complaint.
Price
If you want to pay in cash, the room rates start at $850 to $1,911 per night. (Average of $1,477).
Points Redemption
No, at the moment, there’s no option to redeem points at Eden Rock St Barths.
Get the full lowdown on how you can travel and redeem points at The Points University.
Who Is It For?
Eden Rock St Barths is made for indulgent travelers who want to escape the hubbub of big chain resorts and exchange it for utmost peace beside turquoise waters and powdery white sands. Couples, families, and even solo travelers will find this a true haven.
Eden Rock St Barths Gallery
Eden Rock St Barths – Pool. Image Credit: Eden Rock St Barths
Eden Rock St Barths – Kitchen. Image Credit: Eden Rock St Barths
Eden Rock St Barths – Balcony. Image Credit: Eden Rock St Barths
Eden Rock St Barths – Beach Loungers. Image Credit: Eden Rock St Barths
Cheval Blanc St-Barth
Cheval Blanc St-Barth- Room. Image Credit: Cheval Blanc St-Barth
Eden Rock St Barths may be one of the most historical hotels on the island, but Cheval Blanc St-Barth is a serious contender for being the most enchanting and glamorous.
Location
Bought in 2013 by the LVMH group, Cheval Blanc St-Barth is a hideaway for some of Hollywood’s elites. Aside from its amazing facilities and location, the property promises absolute privacy – not even releasing the names of its A-list clientele.
Cheval Blanc Randheli is considered one of Maldive’s finest so it’s no surprise that Cheval Blanc St-Barth was awarded the famed Palace distinction.
To reach the resort, you need to book a flight to reach the island of St. Barts. Smaller charter planes as well as private planes fly into the St. Barth’s Gustaf III Airport (SBH) regularly. Once you arrive on the island, a private car will welcome you and take you to the hotel.
When you arrive, you’ll be greeted by the concierge, called Alchemists, and the hotel staff, called Ambassadors.
Room
Cheval Blanc St-Barth – Bedroom. Image Credit: Cheval Blanc St-Barth
Cheval Blanc St-Barth emphasizes tranquility and privacy, providing only 61 rooms and suites.
Every room has a plush bed to guarantee a great night’s sleep. They include a terrace offering fantastic views of the ocean. Lovely patterned rugs provide interest and color without overwhelming the space. A lot of the decor is in white but with signature ochres, pinks, and sea blues.
Lovely wicker chairs, sleek black tables including standard modern additions like a minibar, fridge, and in-room amenities like flip flops, and beach bags are here too. Higher-end rooms include distinct dining spaces, multiple bedrooms, living rooms, a kitchen, and even a private pool.
The bathroom is jaw-dropping with a freestanding white tub, attractive wood floors, excellent showers, and a toilet. Exclusive Guerlain bath products create a spa-like feel. Even the staff will prepare a bath filled with dreamy essential oils to help you relax each night.
Amenities
Cheval Blanc St-Barth – Yoga. Image Credit: Cheval Blanc St-Barth
For amenities, there’s a dedicated Guerlain Spa where guests can enjoy themselves with an invigorating massage. It’s usually followed by exquisite post-spa treats that make the experience even more memorable.
Yoga enthusiasts will love the private classes offered by a renowned yoga instructor. There are also barre classes and hiking activities available for those who want to explore the beauty of the island.
Other things you can enjoy include a lovely swimming pool with beach loungers and cabanas, a captivating beach outside the property doorstep, a fitness center, and high-end shops nearby.
Food and Dining
Cheval Blanc St-Barth – Dining. Image Credit: Cheval Blanc St-Barth
With everything else above par, you can expect Cheval Blanc St-Barth to deliver only the most premium dishes for guests.
La Case is headed by chef Jean Imbert, highlighting exquisite Caribbean cuisine. Local flavors and ingredients are a priority in each dish, ensuring guests can indulge themselves.
On the other hand, La Cabane is a beachside spot perfect for breakfast and lunch. Here, you can go for casual eats with a twist. Think the iconic Flamands burger or the signature artichoke salad.
If you fancy a cocktail or two, drop by The White Bar where expert staff can whip up a refreshing cocktail from sun-up to sun-down.
Staff and Guest Services
Cheval Blanc St-Barth prides itself not just on its world-class amenities, but its outstanding staff. The staff goes above and beyond, memorizing your itinerary throughout your stay, paying attention to the little details without you even realizing it, and more. It’s this exemplary service that makes visiting Cheval Blanc St-Barth even more magical than it is.
Price
Starter rooms at Cheval Blanc St-Barth are understandably pricey, starting at $950 per night to $2,657 per night (average $1,450).
Points Redemption
No, at the moment, there’s no points redemption available at Cheval Blanc St-Barth.
Who Is It For?
While it’s popular with celebrities, there’s a mix of people who visit Cheval Blanc St-Barth, all of which seek the ultimate slice of paradise. Honeymooners and couples will find Cheval Blanc St-Barth to be a sanctuary of luxury, calm, and relaxation.
Cheval Blanc St-Barth Gallery
Cheval Blanc St-Barth – Pool Beds. Image Credit: Cheval Blanc St-Barth
Cheval Blanc St-Barth – Loungers. Image Credit: Cheval Blanc St-Barth
Cheval Blanc St-Barth – Bathroom. Image Credit: Cheval Blanc St-Barth
Best For: Which Resort Should You Go For?
| Winner | What Makes It Great | |
| Best for Food | Cheval Blanc St-Barth | Cheval Blanc St-Barth has two stunning restaurants serving only the most unique dishes with a Caribbean flair. |
| Best for Pools | Cheval Blanc St-Barth | While the pool isn’t lavish, it is well-kept and elegant, perfect for lounging and swimming. |
| Best for Spa | Cheval Blanc St-Barth | Guerlain Spa is a highlight at the resort. It might be small but the service is top-notch! |
| Best for Beaches | Cheval Blanc St-Barth | Flamands Beach is a gem with its powdery sands and brilliant waters. |
| Best For Adults | Tie | Both resorts are perfect for honeymooners and couples. |
| Best for Families | Eden Rock St Barths | Although Cheval Blanc St-Barth is also family-friendly, Eden Rock St Barths would be a better choice if you want to bring the entire family. |
| Best Location | Tie | If you want historical flair, go with Eden Rock but if you’re after a great beach, Cheval Blanc’s prime spot at Flamands Beach is unbeatable. |
| Best for a Calm Vacation | Tie | St. Barts may be considered a luxe party town, but both these resorts prioritize privacy, wellness, and relaxation. |
| Best for Diving or Snorkeling | Tie | There are plenty of corals and fish in the waters near Eden’s Rock and Cheval Blanc. |
| Best for Service | Tie | Guests rave about the exemplary service they received from both of these properties. Their staff are excellent at making guests feel truly special. |
| Most Exclusive | Cheval Blanc St-Barth | With A-list celebrities flocking to the resort over and over again, it’s no secret Cheval Blanc St-Barth offers absolute exclusivity. |
Wrapping Up
If you’re ready to treat yourself to a lavish vacation, consider making either Eden Rock St Barths or Cheval Blanc St-Barth your next getaway destination!
These two resorts promise privacy, superb amenities, and the most wonderful service to ensure your dream vacation lives up to the hype.
Safe travels!